Edguy - Tinnitus Sanctus
Other than the amateurish debut, this one might get the least acclaim among the fans. Not sure. Regardless, it's my favorite album of theirs, which I seem to be the only person who says. For me, it hits the right balance between being silly and serious, cheesy without being embarrassing.
Iron Maiden - The Final Frontier
Sure, it's longer than it needs to be, but that's the only real complaint I can level against this. I love this whole era of Iron Maiden, and sometimes this is my favorite album of theirs. "Coming Home" and "Mother Of Mercy" are great short songs, and this one has my favorite of Steve's ten-minute epics too.
Dio - Master Of The Moon
I don't know what people hear that they think "Magica" was better than this record. That one was a steaming pile of shit, while this one is a perfectly acceptable record that's more enjoyable than "Angry Machines" or "Killing The Dragon". I guess I like Dio and Goldy together more than a lot of people.