Peak vs. Consistency

Author:Thy Sentinel
Date:2020-04-13 19:34:07
I would like to ask this question again. Last time the thread got derailed quickly but:

In your overall opinion / ranking of the band, which matters more: PEAK or CONSISTENCY?

To me, examples of inconsistent band with great peak are Queensryche and Tad Morose. To me, very consistent bands that never released a true masterpiece of an album are Tarot and Morgana Lefay. But let's not get lost in the particulars.

Of course, we all prefer bands that have both (Overkill, Running Wild, etc.). But foot to the fire, which type do you prefer?

np: Overkill "Wings of War"

"The horizon is my finish line, the very edge of earth" ("Vysotsky in English" project,
Main Page