I absolutely love about half their songs. That’s a good enough ratio to me.

Not for me. That's way too high a failure rate.

I don’t expect to love the whole thing but even 5-6 great songs is great.

Those kinds of albums get forgotten about by me pretty easily. I don't put on records very often if I have to skip a bunch of songs. I might have the good songs saved somewhere, but I mostly listen to albums in full, rather than bursts of three or four tracks.